10 thoughts on “DESI, Sedona and Barcelona”

  1. After many years in academe and among academic researchers, I can testify that it is often very difficult for an academic researcher to build a a production quality tool. They build a “proof of concept” but these tools often lack the robustness and error handling critical to a successful production level tool. Let’s hope that we have better luck in the e-discovery community, and I think conferences like these are a major step forward.

    I wonder too about getting this material into law school curricula. We’ve heard that is not enough e-discovery in law school curricula, how long will it take to get search techniques and criteria?

    Altogether, a great blog.

  2. Johnette,

    I agree completely that more information about the subject of search and information retrieval should be part of the law school curriculum, as part of either specifically tailored e-discovery courses, or even as assigned readings in the more usual run of civil procedure and federal courts classes.

    Aside from Ralph’s two books (which do touch on the subject of search and of course should be required reading everywhere!), there is a new casebook out, by Judge Shira A. Scheindlin, Daniel J. Capra, and The Sedona Conference, titled “Electronic Discovery and Digital Evidence: Cases and Materials (West 2009). Chapter V(B), pp. 226-249, specifically deals with “Search Methods,” and go into many of the topics covered by the Sedona Conference’s Commentary on Search and Information Retrieval. I assisted in that effort and am also working on other material for use in law schools, but the point is well taken: we should be out there teaching what we know to the next generation.

  3. In my opinion, the subject of how to search for information (information science/library science) and its automated delivery given an information need(information retrieval) should be part of the curriculum not just of legal professionals but of every citizen on this planet. In an information society that is sustained by an information economy, we had better teach even primary school kids what information is, that despite its intangible nature, and what problems society faces surrounding this area (authority/credibility, censorship, technical failure, cybercrime/disinformation/information warfare). Most of these have some legal aspect.

  4. I totally agree with these sentiments. We have a lot of work to do in the education field. Next Spring I will teach what is to my knowledge the first advanced e-discovery law school class in the country. You must have taken the first level e-discovery class as a prerequisite. It will be seminar style and students will pick a topic to go deep and write a paper. Students will be graded on original research, the quality of the paper and class discussion. Since Jason Baron and Ken Withers have both been speakers at UF in the past year, and Bill Hamilton has done a great job with this program, I am sure we will get a good turn out for the advanced course. I am also confident that several of the advanced students will pick the topic of search as it is the core issue in e-discovery.

    We are working on developing the leaders of tomorrow, but obviously have a long way to go. Every law school in the country should do this, not just the University of Florida. Call the Dean of your alma mater or local law school and ask them about it.

  5. Pingback: seo news

Leave a Reply